|
Supplements
can help active
seniors bulk
up
TRALEE
PEARCE
FROM WEDNESDAY'S
GLOBE AND MAIL
OCTOBER 3, 2007
AT 7:46 AM EDT
Seniors
looking to get
more bang for
their exercise
buck may benefit
from popping
an over-thecounter
nutritional
supplement every
day, according
to new research.
Exercise has
already been
proven to combat
the loss of
muscle mass.
But adding two
supplements
commonly found
in health-food
stores, creatine
monohydrate
and conjugated
linoleic acid
(CLA), can boost
the effects
of exercise,
according to
research published
today in the
peer-reviewed
online journal
of the Public
Library of Science,
PLoS One.
Creatine, a
compound produced
by the body
and naturally
occurring in
meat that helps
supply energy
to muscles,
and CLA, a naturally
occurring fatty
acid, appeared
to help study
participants
build muscle
while shedding
fat, says Mark
Tarnopolsky,
the lead researcher
and a professor
of medicine
and pediatrics
at McMaster
University.
The supplements
appear to work
only in combination
with exercise,
and most of
the benefit
comes from activity.
"No one
has a weight-loss
miracle cure
- if they did,
they'd be a
billionaire,"
Dr. Tarnopolsky
said. "If
you're sitting
on your keister,
the creatine
does nothing
for you and
the CLA probably
does nothing
for you."
Thirty-nine
people aged
65 or older
took part in
the trial, in
which all performed
regular resistance
training over
the course of
six months.
All showed improvements
in function
and strength,
but those who
took the supplements
instead of a
placebo showed
a greater improvement
in muscle mass
and fat loss.
Those who took
the supplements
in the study
on average gained
2.1 kilograms
of muscle mass
and lost 1.9
kilograms of
body fat. Those
who took a placebo
gained 0.9 kilograms
of muscle mass
and lost only
400 grams of
body fat.
While he studied
only the senior
demographic,
Dr. Tarnopolsky
says he can
see baby boomers
extrapolating
from the study's
results.
"For the
overweight,
middle-aged
person or the
older adult
who is starting
to exercise
... at least
in the short
term this combination
does appear
to get people
to where they
want to go a
little bit faster."
Previous studies
had shown creatine
worked to increase
muscle mass,
but had no effect
on fat. Data
on CLA were
mixed for humans;
animal studies
had shown the
supplement's
ability to decrease
fat.
Creatine has
also received
somewhat of
a bad rap: Though
legal, it's
been linked
with steroid
use and other
illegal doping
in the world
of sport. But
athletes take
the compound
at much higher
doses, and even
at those doses
Dr. Tarnopolsky
questions whether
they would be
performance-enhancing.
To maximize
safety, Dr.
Tarnopolsky
consulted hundreds
of studies on
creatine as
well as on CLA
to
determine the
lowest possible
dose. He administered
five grams of
creatine and
six grams of
CLA daily.
Without
supplements,
adults normally
get between
one and 1.5
grams a day
of creatine
from food.
In
some Nordic
countries, he
says, a diet
high in cold-water
fish results
in intakes of
close to five
grams a day.
The
only side effects
at the dosages
he administered
are gastrointestinal
upset in 5 per
cent of people.
But
he warns that
some nutritional
supplements
contain 20-gram
doses. "All
bets are off
if you put someone
on 20 g,"
he says.
Hamilton
resident Chris
Dunn, 71, who
took supplements
in the study,
has no doubt
the combination
worked for him.
He noticed a
marked increase
in strength
during his weight-training
sessions. "It
was amazing;
quite noticeable,"
he says.
Elizabeth
and Michael,
who asked that
their last names
not be used,
described themselves
as anti-vitamin
and say they
were skeptical
of the supplements.
Already active
at 75 and 77
respectively
- the married
couple regularly
ski and hike
Ontario's Bruce
Trail -they
volunteered
for the study
primarily for
the supervised
exercise program.
Both say they
feel they benefited.
"Health
doesn't come
in a bottle,"
Elizabeth says.
"But I
feel pretty
good."
Michael, a former
family doctor,
says he wants
to read the
results of the
study before
deciding whether
they might add
a supplement
to their breakfast
routine.
Dr. Tarnopolsky
suspects further
research may
show that the
effects drop
off after six
months, in which
case the supplements
may only be
of benefit in
the early stages
of a new exercise
program. But
that's a good
thing, he says.
"If
people see changes
happening, they're
more likely
to stay with
the program,"
he says. "Any
way we can improve
compliance and
get people to
stick with exercise,
we're going
to see the effects.
Folks even in
their 90s can
improve."
©
Copyright 2007
CTVglobemedia
Publishing Inc.
All Rights Reserved.
CTV l b di
globeandmail.com
and The Globe
and Mail are
divisions of
CTVglobemedia
Publishing Inc.,
444
Front St. W.,
Toronto, ON
Canada M5V 2S9
Phillip Crawley,
Publisher
<
Back to Info
Centre
.
SupplementsCanada,
or the operating
limited company,
authors or any
personnel contributing
to this document
do not assume
any liability,
or no responsibilities,
for any products
results, personal
results, all
information,
directions,
advice, or recommendations
on this document.
As a result
of this document
evaluating,
recommending,
and providing
all information
contained expressed
opinions are
the companies
own opinions,
and the companies
own opinions
only, and are
not meant to
be interpreted
as conclusive.
This document
is sole and
in part to educate
people about
natural supplementation
and helping
create a drug
free environment.
Always consult
a medical doctor,
or get a medical
opinion first,
if you are unsure
about any new
sports nutrition,
exercising,
or any kind
of dietary supplement
use, even though
supplements
are natural
and safe to
use, there have
been few cases
of people getting
some harmful
effects from
different supplements
whether it being
from regular
use, reaction,
misuse, or abuse.
Sport supplementation
should be used
by persons 18
years and older.
The information
on this document
is pending copyright
SupplementsCanada
2006.
|